Excuse for not joining rehab program rejected

An employee must have a reasonable excuse for refusing to participate in a workplace rehabilitation program – merely being dissatisfied with it is not an acceptable reason for non-compliance.


The Administrative Appeals Tribunal of Australia (AATA) found that it appeared that an employee’s main reason for refusing to participate was her preference to work four days per week instead of five.


Her case was also undermined by surveillance footage that indicated that she had exaggerated her symptoms, and some credibility issues with the evidence of other witnesses.

Facts of case


Catrina Oliver was employed as an executive assistant by the Department of Social Services (DSS). She was awarded workers’ compensation for inflammatory and sprain-type injuries, including carpal tunnel syndrome, to her left wrist. Over three years, she had surgery and several attempts to return to work, before taking maternity leave. Several different rehabilitation providers were used during this time.


The DSS referred her to an occupational physician, who reported that her condition was unlikely to resolve in the foreseeable future, but there were no objective medical reasons why she could not return to full-time work. The physician prepared a return-to-work plan that included graduated return to full-time work hours over three months, plus ergonomic adjustments to her workplace, limits placed on lifting weights and keyboard use, and use of voice-activated software. 


Ms Oliver claimed that the program was unsuitable because it caused her “unbearable pain and constant stress and anxiety”. She requested a new program that included the alternative of working four days per week instead of five, but the DSS refused. She requested that Comcare’s decision be reviewed, but it found in the employer’s favour, so she appealed to the AATA.


She claimed that the pain amounted to a reasonable excuse for refusing the program and that the voice-activated software was of limited help to her because of workplace background noise and its limited task capability. 


However, surveillance footage of the employee performing activities outside work, such as putting her children into her car with both arms, indicated that she was not suffering severe pain and had exaggerated her symptoms. The nature of her complaints about the program suggested that her real motive was a preference to work four days per week, which would also assist her childcare arrangements.


Comcare claimed that the medical evidence showed that its proposed rehabilitation program would not increase the level of pain when combined with the other proposed support measures.


The AATA questioned the credibility of some of Ms Oliver’s evidence and that of her witnesses.

Decision


The AATA found that the employer’s rehabilitation program was reasonable, based on a suitable assessment of Ms Oliver, appropriate and compliant with legislation. This finding took into account each of the following: potential to reduce future compensation payable, cost of the program, benefits to Ms Oliver’s employment, the potential psychological cost of not providing the program, the relative merits of alternative actions, and her attitude towards the program. Therefore, she was obligated to undertake the program.


The AATA’s decision was based mainly on the evidence in relation to her ongoing level of pain, as there was limited evidence available in relation to the “stress” claim.


The AATA upheld a previous decision to suspend her entitlement to workers’ compensation payments until she took part in the employer-provided rehabilitation program. 


The bottom line: A tribunal does not have to establish the reason why an employee chooses not to participate in an employer-provided rehabilitation program. Therefore, the employer’s claim in this case that the employee wanted a four-day week to suit her childcare responsibilities did not have to be considered. The tribunal has to decide whether the employee had a reasonable excuse for refusing to participate. The employee’s excuse has to be objective, not just rational. In this case, there was strong evidence that the employee had no reasonable reason for refusing the employer’s program, she just preferred her alternative of working fewer days per week.

Decision


Contact Us

Zenergy News

WHS news Australia
By Dean Woods • November 15, 2026
SWA updates 15 Codes of Practice for the WEL deadline, Australian Workplace Health and Safety Awards winners, and a $150k tree-cutting fall fine. WHS news Australia
workplace exposure limits
By Dean Woods • November 15, 2026
Safe Work Australia has updated 15 Codes of Practice ahead of the 1 December workplace exposure limits start. A practical WEL checklist for HSE leaders.
2026 Australian Workplace Health and Safety Awards promo slide with purple-orange gradient background and white text
By Dean Woods • November 15, 2026
Woolworths, Vodafone and Brisbane Catholic Education among the 2026 Australian Workplace Health and Safety Awards winners — from proud sponsor Zenergy. Australian Workplace Health and Safety Awards
Mercedes just won the 2026 Formula 1 Constructors' Championship
By Dean Woods • November 10, 2026
Toto Wolff has a philosophy that every CEO, operational leader and WHS professional should consider: "We blame the problem and not the person."
By Dean Woods • November 3, 2026
Welcome to Take 5, Zenergy's five-minute scan of what's moving in Australian workplace health and safety, workers compensation, and people and culture. This week: Victoria puts a date and a dollar figure on on-the-spot fines, the Fair Work Commission's generative AI rules take effect, and Safe Work Australia's annual data lands with a confronting headline number. 1. Victoria locks in on-the-spot fines for falls and SWMS breaches From 31 March 2027, WorkSafe Victoria inspectors will be able to issue infringement notices — on-the-spot fines — under the Occupational Health and Safety Amendment (Infringement Offences) Regulations 2026. The confirmed offences: failing to use a control measure for a fall risk (up to $2,091 for a company, $418.20 for an individual), starting high-risk construction work without a Safe Work Method Statement, and failing to keep a SWMS or required fall-risk records readily accessible (up to $1,254.60 for a company). The Victorian Government confirmed the start date and amounts on 21 October. No new duties are created — these are existing obligations. What changes is the speed of enforcement: a breach an inspector once handled with a notice or a long prosecution can now cost money the same day. We unpack what it means, and what the courts are doing in parallel, in this week's deep dive. Also on the radar: Australia's new Workplace Exposure Limits replace the old exposure standards from 1 December 2026 — one month out. If your chemical register and SDS library haven't been checked against the new limits, now is the time (Safe Work Australia). Sources: WorkSafe Victoria — New infringement notices for falls and high-risk construction work offences (worksafe.vic.gov.au/new-infringement-notices-falls-and-high-risk-construction-work-offences); Premier of Victoria media release, 21 October 2026 (premier.vic.gov.au/labor-brings-spot-fines-unsafe-worksites); Safe Work Australia — New workplace exposure limits (WEL) to apply from 1 December 2026 (safeworkaustralia.gov.au). 2. Key dates: Movember and the Australian Workplace Health & Safety Awards Movember runs all month, putting men's health — mental health and suicide prevention, prostate and testicular cancer — on the agenda. It's a natural fit for safety teams in male-dominated industries: 93% of the workers who died at work in 2025 were men (Safe Work Australia). A toolbox talk, a fundraising crew or a wellbeing check-in all count. On the calendar: the 2026 Australian Workplace Health & Safety Awards run 12–13 November in NSW, and AIHS branches host events through the fortnight, including the South Australian Safety Breakfast on 5 November (AIHS events calendar). Sources: Movember (movember.com); AIHS events (aihs.org.au); Safe Work Australia — Key WHS Statistics Australia 2026. 3. People & culture: the Fair Work Commission's generative AI rules are now in force New Fair Work Commission guidance on the use of generative AI in Commission matters took effect on 20 October. Anyone who uses generative AI to help prepare a document lodged in a case must disclose that use — and a person must verify that every fact, case and quote in the document exists and says what it's claimed to say. Asking another AI tool to check doesn't count. The guidance reaches further than many employers expect: an HR adviser representing their own employer falls within the definition of a professional representative. Documents that don't comply can be given less weight, disregarded, or in serious cases see the matter dismissed with costs. If your HR team touches unfair dismissal responses, witness statements or submissions, map where AI is being used and put a verification step in writing (Fair Work Commission; HRD Australia, 20 October 2026). Sources: Fair Work Commission (fwc.gov.au); HRD Australia — Fair Work Commission AI disclosure rules now in force for employers, 20 October 2026 (hcamag.com). 4. Job market pulse: vacancies ease, construction holds The ABS's latest Job Vacancies release (August 2026 quarter, published 1 October) counted 325,000 vacancies nationally, down 0.9% over the quarter and 1.3% over the year. Private sector vacancies fell 2.0% to 286,300 while public sector vacancies rose 7.8% to 38,700 — and construction vacancies held broadly steady at around 20,000. For HSE hiring, that reads as a market that has cooled from its peak but is still competitive for proven safety talent, particularly in construction and infrastructure. Sources: ABS — Job Vacancies, Australia, August 2026 (abs.gov.au); SEEK (seek.com.au). 5. Industry story of the week: 222 lives — Australia's worst year since 2012 Safe Work Australia's Key Work Health and Safety Statistics Australia 2026, released in October, confirms that 222 workers died at work in 2025 — the highest annual toll since 2012 and well above the five-year average of 197. Vehicle incidents accounted for 92 deaths, falls from height 28 and falling objects 21: together, nearly two-thirds of the total. Construction recorded 41 deaths; transport, postal and warehousing the most of any industry at 61. The compensation data tells its own story. Around 147,200 serious claims were lodged in 2024–25, and mental health conditions now account for 17,900 of them — 12.2% of the total, up 169% since 2014–15. A typical mental health claim involves a median 34.8 weeks off work and $68,600 in compensation, roughly five times the time lost of other serious claims. "The data is confronting, but it also tells us where action is needed," said Safe Work Australia CEO Marie Boland. Sources: Safe Work Australia — Key WHS Statistics Australia 2026 (data.safeworkaustralia.gov.au/reports/key-whs-statistics-australia/latest-release) and media release, October 2026 (safeworkaustralia.gov.au). Featured role: Health & Safety Manager - $175,000 + Sydney NSW | Permanent, full time Our client is a large, well-established organisation operating across a diverse range of business functions and operational environments. With a broad workforce and complex risk profile, the organisation is committed to strengthening its health and safety practices, improving consistency and embedding a proactive approach to risk management. Apply via the Zenergy job board —for a confidential conversation call the team on 1300 333 400 Hiring HSE talent, or weighing your own next move? Talk to a Zenergy consultant — 20 years of trusted partnerships across every level of HSE leadership. Visit zenergygroup.com.au.
WorkSafe Victoria on-the-spot fines
By Dean Woods • November 3, 2026
From 31 March 2027 WorkSafe Victoria can fine fall-risk and SWMS breaches on the spot. What's changing, why enforcement is hardening, how to prepare.
More Posts