Competency and supervision, guilty verdict returned in landmark WHS prosecution over road accident

A national employer was found guilty of eight WHS charges, relating to its failure to adequately check the competencies of a new hire, who later caused a road accident resulting in two deaths.


South Australian Magistrate Simon Smart found Cleanaway Operations Pty Ltd (formerly Transpacific Industries Pty Ltd) breached its duty of care when it failed properly assess driver Darren Hicks’s competency to drive the manual road tanker or control it on the downhill parts of the route he had to travel. Hicks had only recently obtained an unrestricted heavy vehicle licence and been employed by Cleanaway for just five days, Magistrate Smart found.


The magistrate said the company should have been alert to the associated risks, but had failed to take any “obvious, rudimentary and necessary“ safety measures before assigning him his task on that day.


In August 2014, Hicks lost control of the tanker truck he was driving and it reached speeds of more than 150km/h before colliding with three cars at the intersection of the South Eastern Freeway and Cross Road in Adelaide. Two people died from their injuries and two others were seriously injured, including Hicks.


As reported by OHS Alert in August 2016, national WHS regulator Comcare charged Cleanaway with eight breaches of the Commonwealth WHS Act. Each charge, made under section 32, carried a maximum penalty of $1.5 million. Comcare alleged Cleanaway breached its duty of care in failing to provide Hicks with adequate training and supervision, including on “safely negotiating the freeway’s steep descent from the Adelaide Hills, using arrester beds and driving a heavy vehicle with a manual gearbox“.


The employer pleaded not guilty but Magistrate Smart found this week that each charge was made out.


Between obtaining his heavy vehicle licence and the day of the incident Hicks had not driven a heavy vehicle with a manual transmission, the Magistrate found.


Cleanaway had only assessed the driver in driving an automatic truck but assigned him a manual truck on the day of the accident. Hicks did not recall having been asked by anyone at Cleanaway if he had driven this type of vehicle before or being provided training on how to drive it, the court heard.


Magistrate Smart said it was beyond reasonable doubt that Cleanaway recognised the importance of undertaking competency-based driver assessments to reduce safety risk. It employed trainers and provided extra vehicles for this purpose.


But it failed to maintain a system of work that prevented Hicks from driving without proper supervision until his competency in relation to all the vehicles he was required to drive was determined, he said.


“An assessment by [Cleanaway] itself of the competence of the driver Hicks to perform the identified task would have given [Cleanaway] direct knowledge of his level of competence to undertake those tasks,” Magistrate Smart said.


A proper check of his competencies would have provided Cleanaway with the knowledge to only assign him tasks of which he was capable, thus minimising the risk of a crash, he said.


Comcare v Cleanaway Operations Pty Ltd (Acn 010 745 383) Transpacific Industries Pty Ltd [2021] SAMC 54 (19 April 2021)

Contact Us

Zenergy News

Directors' duties for psych risks unpacked in new report
April 23, 2025
The WHS obligations of company directors include taking reasonable steps to understand the psychological hazards in their workplaces, and this is a "personal" prosecutable duty, a new guide for directors warns. Directors' obligations include establishing that their organisations and their management "are equipped with appropriate resources and processes to eliminate or minimise these risks to the extent that is reasonably practicable", the guide by the Australian Institute of Company Directors and law firm King & Wood Mallesons says. Most of any organisation's work to address psychosocial hazards will be "driven by management", given the complexity of the risks and the deep operational knowledge required to guide action, it says. "The board plays a supporting role in constructively challenging these efforts and maintaining oversight of how effective psychosocial risk management contributes to broader organisational culture and leadership." Under Australia's national model WHS laws – adopted by all jurisdictions other than Victoria, which has similar legislation – officers have a duty to exercise due diligence to confirm their organisation is meeting its WHS obligations. (See section 27 of NSW's version of the laws, for example.) This duty is a "personal duty, meaning [officers] can be prosecuted for failing to meet their due diligence obligations", the guide says. "Prosecution typically requires proof that the officer failed to take reasonable steps to comply with their duty, assessed in the context of the organisation's overall safety and health management system," it says. These due diligence obligations apply to paid directors, and are "recommended" for volunteer directors, who can be prosecuted in limited circumstances. "While non-executive directors have not been the focus of WHS regulators to date, this can change, and regulatory expectations are rising," the guide notes. According to the 12-page document , company boards and governance play a crucial role in ensuring psychosocial risks are managed effectively. Directors must oversee management's efforts at identifying and implementing control measures, set expectations and confirm that the necessary frameworks are in place. "This includes seeking information, reviewing board reports, assessing organisational culture, and challenging management where needed to strengthen risk controls," the guide says. Examples of how boards should address the workplace factors that create psychosocial risks include: Overseeing how managers monitor the risks associated with work design by drawing on complaints data, employee surveys, and absence and turnover rates, and engaging regularly with management to assess risks and evaluate measures; Confirming that management is complying with the positive duty to eliminate workplace sexual harassment, and obtaining regular reports on key behavioural risks involving code of conduct breaches and harassment cases; Setting expectations for management to provide workers with practical assistance and timely consultation in the event of organisational change and restructures, which can create significant stress; Engaging with management to review how it is addressing remote work risks, and ensuring there they have a clear policy to guide them in determining when remote arrangements are appropriate; and Overseeing how HR and performance management processes are managed, and confirming that investigation procedures are fair, workers have access to appropriate support, and outcomes are handled as consistently as possible. Governing WHS Psychosocial Risks: A primer for directors, by the Australian Institute of Company Directors and King & Wood Mallesons, April 2025 This article has been reproduced with permission from OHS Alert, and the original version appears at www.ohsalert.com.au.
April 7, 2025
Zenergy recently hosted Women in Safety, a special networking event dedicated to fostering collaboration in the health, safety, and wellbeing sector. Held on March 20, 2025, at The Winery, Surry Hills, this event provided a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere where professionals gathered to exchange insights, share experiences, and build meaningful connections. With attendees from diverse industries—including construction, logistics, corporate sectors, and more—the event highlighted the vital role of women in shaping safer workplaces across Australia.
March 25, 2025
Podcasts have become a dominant force in the world of media, revolutionising how we consume information and entertainment and the WHS, Environment & Sustainability is no different! As the podcast industry continues to expand, listeners are discovering a wealth of benefits, from educational insights to fostering community connections. In this article, we share some of the leading podcasts and why they’ve become a growing part of modern WHS, Environment & Sustainability consumption. Here are some of the leading podcasts that every WHS, Environmental, and Sustainability professional should tune into:
March 24, 2025
Colin Hansen, WHS Director John Holland - M7M12 Project
March 3, 2025
Zenergy invites you to be part of the prestigious 2025 Australian Workplace Health & Safety Awards (AWHSA) —a national platform dedicated to recognising outstanding achievements in workplace health and safety. These awards celebrate individuals and organisations that are making a real impact in fostering safer, healthier work environments.
February 28, 2025
Australia has enacted mandatory sustainability reporting requirements, effective from 1 January 2025, through the Treasury Laws Amendment (Financial Market Infrastructure and Other Measures) Act 2024. These regulations mandate that large entities disclose climate-related financial information as part of their annual reporting obligations.
More Posts