Competency and supervision, guilty verdict returned in landmark WHS prosecution over road accident

A national employer was found guilty of eight WHS charges, relating to its failure to adequately check the competencies of a new hire, who later caused a road accident resulting in two deaths.


South Australian Magistrate Simon Smart found Cleanaway Operations Pty Ltd (formerly Transpacific Industries Pty Ltd) breached its duty of care when it failed properly assess driver Darren Hicks’s competency to drive the manual road tanker or control it on the downhill parts of the route he had to travel. Hicks had only recently obtained an unrestricted heavy vehicle licence and been employed by Cleanaway for just five days, Magistrate Smart found.


The magistrate said the company should have been alert to the associated risks, but had failed to take any “obvious, rudimentary and necessary“ safety measures before assigning him his task on that day.


In August 2014, Hicks lost control of the tanker truck he was driving and it reached speeds of more than 150km/h before colliding with three cars at the intersection of the South Eastern Freeway and Cross Road in Adelaide. Two people died from their injuries and two others were seriously injured, including Hicks.


As reported by OHS Alert in August 2016, national WHS regulator Comcare charged Cleanaway with eight breaches of the Commonwealth WHS Act. Each charge, made under section 32, carried a maximum penalty of $1.5 million. Comcare alleged Cleanaway breached its duty of care in failing to provide Hicks with adequate training and supervision, including on “safely negotiating the freeway’s steep descent from the Adelaide Hills, using arrester beds and driving a heavy vehicle with a manual gearbox“.


The employer pleaded not guilty but Magistrate Smart found this week that each charge was made out.


Between obtaining his heavy vehicle licence and the day of the incident Hicks had not driven a heavy vehicle with a manual transmission, the Magistrate found.


Cleanaway had only assessed the driver in driving an automatic truck but assigned him a manual truck on the day of the accident. Hicks did not recall having been asked by anyone at Cleanaway if he had driven this type of vehicle before or being provided training on how to drive it, the court heard.


Magistrate Smart said it was beyond reasonable doubt that Cleanaway recognised the importance of undertaking competency-based driver assessments to reduce safety risk. It employed trainers and provided extra vehicles for this purpose.


But it failed to maintain a system of work that prevented Hicks from driving without proper supervision until his competency in relation to all the vehicles he was required to drive was determined, he said.


“An assessment by [Cleanaway] itself of the competence of the driver Hicks to perform the identified task would have given [Cleanaway] direct knowledge of his level of competence to undertake those tasks,” Magistrate Smart said.


A proper check of his competencies would have provided Cleanaway with the knowledge to only assign him tasks of which he was capable, thus minimising the risk of a crash, he said.


Comcare v Cleanaway Operations Pty Ltd (Acn 010 745 383) Transpacific Industries Pty Ltd [2021] SAMC 54 (19 April 2021)

Contact Us

Zenergy News

February 11, 2025
A workplace health and safety regulator has explained what the "safest workplaces" look like, in revealing it finalised more than 100 successful safety prosecutions in 2024.
February 11, 2025
Two years after the release of the groundbreaking 2022 Everyday Respect Report, Rio Tinto has undertaken a thorough Progress Review to assess its ongoing cultural transformation. As one of the world’s largest mining companies, Rio Tinto has been working to create a safer, more inclusive workplace culture that fosters respect, productivity, and innovation. The 2024 Progress Review highlights significant strides made, ongoing challenges, and areas requiring further attention. The Journey Towards Cultural Transformation Cultural change is a multi-year effort that requires consistent leadership, structural support, and engagement across all levels of an organization. Since launching its Everyday Respect initiative, Rio Tinto has embedded this agenda into its core business strategy, focusing on reducing bullying, sexual harassment, and racism in the workplace. Key Progress Areas: Increased Awareness and Open Conversations: The public release of the original report acted as a catalyst for change, encouraging more employees to speak up and engage in discussions about respect. Stronger Leadership Commitment: Leaders are playing a more proactive role in championing Everyday Respect, with a focus on psychological safety and inclusive leadership. Enhanced Training and Education: Programs such as Everyday Respect Training and Purple Banners have been widely implemented to build awareness and response capabilities. Facility Upgrades and Safety Improvements: Investments in workplace infrastructure have improved the physical environment, making it more inclusive and conducive to employee well-being. Greater Workforce Diversity: There has been a notable increase in gender and cultural diversity across teams, fostering innovation and improved workplace dynamics. Ongoing Challenges and Areas for Improvement Despite progress, resistance to change remains an obstacle, particularly among certain groups. Survey data indicates that while improvements have been perceived in many areas, instances of bullying, sexual harassment, and racism persist. Key focus areas include: Building Stronger Buy-in: Engaging those who are resistant to cultural change, particularly male employees, to foster a collective commitment to Everyday Respect. Enhancing Reporting Mechanisms: Increasing trust in reporting systems to ensure that employees feel safe and supported when raising concerns. Strengthening Frontline Leadership: Providing additional training and tools to equip supervisors and managers with the skills needed to drive culture change at all levels. Maintaining Momentum: Ensuring that Everyday Respect remains a priority in the face of organizational changes and external pressures. Looking Ahead: Staying the Course The findings from the 2024 Progress Review reaffirm Rio Tinto’s commitment to long-term cultural transformation. While meaningful progress has been made, continued efforts are needed to sustain positive momentum and address persistent challenges. As one employee noted: “ Change is definitely happening, and it will get hard at times. We can’t back away ... I’m here at Rio Tinto because I want to see through this change. We need to stay the course. ” With ongoing leadership, engagement, and strategic initiatives, Rio Tinto is on the path to embedding Everyday Respect across all facets of its global operations, ensuring a safer, more inclusive, and more productive workplace for all employees. See full report “ here ”.
By Shazamme System User October 8, 2024
Australia's dating apps are getting a safety makeover.
By Shazamme System User October 8, 2024
National Safe Work Month
September 19, 2024
Meet the Outstanding 2024 Winners
Australia's highest WHS fine, for manslaughter, becomes law
September 19, 2024
NSW's industrial manslaughter laws
More Posts
Share by: